Science Fair Planner

What Science Fair Judges Look For (Rubric and Tips)

A honey bee gathering nectar from a purple aster flower

Photo: John Severns (Severnjc), Public domain. Image credits

Rubrics vary by fair, but almost all of them reward the same things: a clear question, a fair test, honest data, and a student who understands their own project.

Sample rubric

This is a generic rubric modeled on the categories most school and regional fairs use. Always ask for your fair's actual rubric.

Sample scoring rubric (100 points)
CategoryWhat earns full pointsPoints
Question & researchClear, testable question; background research explains the science; sources cited15
Design & procedureOne independent variable; controls identified; repeated trials; procedure someone else could follow25
Data & analysisOrganized tables, correct graph type, labeled axes, averages; results described accurately20
ConclusionAnswers the question using the data; discusses errors and limits; suggests next steps15
Display & logbookReadable, organized board; dated logbook with raw data10
InterviewStudent explains the project in their own words and answers questions thoughtfully15

Questions judges often ask

  • How did you come up with this idea?
  • What was your independent variable? What did you keep the same?
  • Why did you do that many trials?
  • Was there anything that surprised you?
  • If you did it again, what would you change?
  • How could this be useful in the real world?
  • What does this word on your board mean? (Be ready to define every term you used.)

Preparing your talk

  1. Write a 60–90 second summary: question, what you did, what you found, what it means.
  2. Practice it out loud to a family member, then to someone who doesn't know the project.
  3. Point to your graph when you describe your results.
  4. It's fine to say “I don't know, but I could find out by…” That is a good answer.

What loses points

  • A demonstration (showing a volcano erupt) instead of an experiment that tests a variable.
  • Only one trial.
  • Graphs with no labels or units.
  • A conclusion that doesn't match the data.
  • Work clearly done by an adult. Judges can tell.

Next guide: Science Fair Safety Rules for Students and Families